This is a list of the players who have won the Molten Player of the Year Award multiple times.

Most Times Winner

Wins	Players	Seasons
2	Catherine Carr	2017-18, 2020-21

Only multiple-time winners are listed.

Most Times Winner (Franchise)

Wins	Franchise	Winners
3	Sheffield Hatters	Megan Mullings (2025-26) Sarah Toeaina (2018-19) Stephanie Gandy (2014-15)
3	London Lions	Temi Fagbenle (2023-24) Kiki Herbert-Harrigan (2022-23) Jo Leedham-Warner (2021-22)
2	Sevenoaks Suns	Catherine Carr (2017-18, 2020-21)
2	Nottingham Wildcats	Ashley Harris (2016-17) Amber Stokes (2015-16)